Saturday, Aug 15, 2020 | Last Update : 04:48 PM IST

144th Day Of Lockdown

Maharashtra57273440144219427 Tamil Nadu3262452670155514 Andhra Pradesh2730851807032475 Karnataka2111081281823718 Delhi1506521351084178 Uttar Pradesh140775887862280 West Bengal98459671202059 Telangana9025966196684 Bihar8274154139450 Gujarat71064542382652 Assam5883842326145 Rajasthan5249738235789 Odisha4592731785321 Haryana4163534781483 Madhya Pradesh3902529020996 Kerala3811424922127 Jammu and Kashmir2489717003472 Punjab2390315319586 Jharkhand185168998177 Chhatisgarh12148880996 Uttarakhand96326134125 Goa871259575 Tripura6161417641 Puducherry5382320187 Manipur3752204411 Himachal Pradesh3371218114 Nagaland30119738 Arunachal Pradesh223115923 Chandigarh1595100425 Meghalaya11154986 Sikkim9105101 Mizoram6203230
  Opinion   Columnists  03 Jul 2020  Farrukh Dhondy | In a crisis, is Boris pushing the ‘coconuts’ forward?

Farrukh Dhondy | In a crisis, is Boris pushing the ‘coconuts’ forward?

In his words: "I am just a professional writer, which means I don't do blogs and try and get money for whatever I write."
Published : Jul 4, 2020, 2:18 am IST
Updated : Jul 4, 2020, 2:18 am IST

The word ‘coconut’ is used to abuse people who are deemed to be ‘brown outside and white inside'

Protesters during a Justice for Shukri Abdi demonstration, to support the family in their pursuit of justice, in central London. AFP Photo
 Protesters during a Justice for Shukri Abdi demonstration, to support the family in their pursuit of justice, in central London. AFP Photo


“The fear of fear is fearful
It causes the frail be tearful
The dread of what may
Befall the next day
Kills all prospect of being cheerful”
— From Paperback Raita by Bachchoo


Race and colour are inseparable. Those who were labelled ‘coloured people’ insisted in the 1960s on being called ‘black’ — with the corollary that black was beautiful.

Then the acceptable description was ‘people of colour’, even though the militant Afro-Americans called themselves the Black Panther Party. They didn’t just mean the panther was black.

Other marks of colour, getting away from skin, are the colour of the eyes and the hair. Today’s significant universal movement against racism and its memorials has begun to demand that Jesus of Nazareth be portrayed as he probably was — not as a blonde and blue-eyed white man but as a brownish-skinned and black-haired Semite with dark eyes.


A million or more depictions in churches and even Renaissance paintings will have to be taken down or carefully painted over.

Which brings me, gentle reader, to the portraiture of Zarathustra, the prophet who invented monotheism. In every Zoroastrian household in which his portrait hangs, including the household of my grandparents in which I grew up, he was depicted by a German artist as a fair-skinned fellow with flowing brown hair and a beard.

This is obviously a European conceit which we hapless Parsis have adopted. Zarathustra, or ‘Jarthost’ as we Parsis call him, was an Afghan Persian and would have had features more like my second cousin twice removed (each time by the police) Rustom Immoralearningswalla, than like old Hans or Fritz Hoffman dressed in white robes and a turban.


Pointing this out to my devout Parsi community won’t compel the majority to take down this German portrayal, even if they are told that they are praying to Ahura Mazda in front of a portrait of a mythical Santa Claus.

The colour of icons is only problematic if those who use them as intermediaries for the worship of God are at all conscious of the racial divides that scour human history.

After the murder of George Floyd in the US and the movements of people black and white, in the US and now in the UK, to put the histories of the oppression of blacks by whites behind us, questions of colour enter politics, seriously and frivolously.             


Interviewers on TV, bringing up the topic of the progress of black and brown people in Britain asked the health secretary Matt Hancock how many black and brown colleagues were in the present Cabinet. He fumbled the answer, saying he hadn’t counted.

Pranksters on Facebook and other devices got hold of or photo-shopped a picture of Prime Minister Boris Johnson surrounded by the black and Asian members of his cabinet — the likes of Rishi Sunak, Priti Patel, James Cleverly, etc. The pranksters labelled the photograph “Me and My Coconuts”. Now this phrase may mean nothing to people unfamiliar with rude British name-calling.

The word ‘coconut’ is used to abuse people who are deemed to be ‘brown outside and white inside’.


There are other metaphors, such as ‘Bounty Bar’, which is a chocolate case with white coconut filling inside.

The more serious attention to colour in the UK arises from the fact that black and Asian people seem to be more susceptible than the white population to the Covid-19 bug.

There is no scientific theory to account for this but the glaring statistic tells us that a disproportionate number of black and Asian people have died through this viral infection. All sorts of unproven theories have been put forward to account for this, one being that Black and Asian people have less vitamin D in their bodies.

The more probable explanation is that they live in communities where the population density and the density of people per household is significantly greater than that of ‘white’ areas.


Another explanation is that black and Asian people are disproportionately represented in the workforces of hospitals and care homes which puts doctors, nurses, hospital cleaners, ambulance workers and carers at greater risk.

This is true of other professions, such as transport where bus drivers, for instance, are forced into contact with far more people than the stock-market-walla who conducts business on his phone and computer from his back garden or country villa.

This possible explanation brings to mind a childhood memory. In my grandfather’s house in Pune, all those decades ago, we had a cook called Hukam Ali.

Before entering the culinary services Hukums, as we called him, had been inducted into the British Indian army and taken in the late 1930s to Ethiopia to fight the war against the Italian invasion of Africa.


He would recount how regiments from Australia and other parts of the British empire were gathered there. He would say that when the Italian assault began a cry would inevitably go up: “saarey chillaaney laggey — ‘Kaaley koo aagey dhuklo’” — “They all began to shout push the blacks forward.” “Kya bathaaoon, apney bahoth log mar gaye…” —“What to say? Many of us died!”

Rather than any genetic explanation or lack of vitamins, the larger number of deaths among blacks and Asians through Covid may simply have a “kaaley-koo-aagey-dhuklo” origin.

Which brings me, gentle reader, to a rather unworthy thought – call it a conspiracy theory though I hate them. Kaaley koo aagey dhuklo.


It occurs to me that BoJo is very aware that with the certainty now of Britain leaving the European Union, with the US framing all manner of untenable conditions which put America first, the UK is going to be in deep economic trouble. National debt, unemployment, huge welfare bills, a bankrupt health service, rising crime and jail statistics and other disasters will follow.

So, has BoJo very cunningly pushed the ‘coconuts’ forward — an Asian Chancellor in poor Rishi Sunak and a Home Secretary in Priti ‘clueless’ Patel to take the inevitably-coming flak? Kaaley koo aagey dhuklo indeed!

Tags: uk covid-19, racism in uk