Saturday, Apr 20, 2024 | Last Update : 11:02 PM IST

  Opinion   Oped  26 Mar 2017  Discourse: Forgive but do not forget

Discourse: Forgive but do not forget

Published : Mar 26, 2017, 3:26 am IST
Updated : Mar 26, 2017, 6:35 am IST

Shashi Tharoor is seeking precisely this when he demands that Britain apologise and compensate India for its outrageous plunder.

The British seized one of the richest countries in the world and, over 200 years of colonial rule, reduced it to one of the poorest, most diseased and most illiterate countries on earth.
 The British seized one of the richest countries in the world and, over 200 years of colonial rule, reduced it to one of the poorest, most diseased and most illiterate countries on earth.

Corrective justice. What is it and how often does it occur? The apology and setting up of a $8.5-million fund by Japan for using young women as sex slaves during World War II marks a watershed moment. The UK apologised for the torture of Kenyans and paid compensation. The US has apologised for injecting Guatemalans with the syphilis virus to test antibiotics, but reparation was not forthcoming. Apologies and reparations may be symbolic but admittance of guilt is necessary if we are to call ourselves a civilisation. Shashi Tharoor is seeking precisely this when he demands that Britain apologise and compensate India for its outrageous plunder. But let us pause a moment. What about our attitude towards our own people — the Dalits? Atrocities against them continue to date. Who is going to say sorry and when?

Most of us Indians have tended not to dwell on the country’s colonial past. Britain’s shambolic withdrawal from India in 1947 after two centuries of imperial rule was curiously without rancour, even though that original Brexit savagely partitioned the country and left it to tear itself apart. Indeed India chose to remain in the Commonwealth as a Republic and maintained cordial relations with the former imperial overlords. When Winston Churchill, some years after Indian Independence, asked Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, who had spent more than a decade of his life in British jails, how he was so devoid of bitterness, Nehru replied: “We were taught by a great man [Mahatma Gandhi] never to fear and never to hate.”

Whether this was a national strength or a civilisational weakness, India has long refused to bear any grudge against Britain for 200 years of imperial enslavement, plunder and exploitation. It was therefore something of a surprise for me when a speech I made at the Oxford Union in the summer of 2015 decrying the iniquities of British colonialism went viral, with one post racking up more than 3 million hits in 48 hours and the speech being replicated on multiple other sites across the globe.

Right-wing critics of my politics suspended their “trolling” of me on social media to hail my speech. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha, Sumitra Mahajan, went out of her way to laud me at a function attended by the Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, who then congratulated me publicly for having said “the right things at the right place”. Schools and colleges played the speech to their students; one university, the Central University of Jammu, organised a daylong seminar at which eminent scholars addressed specific points I had raised. Hundreds of articles were written, for and against what I had said.

Two years later, I still keep meeting strangers who come up to me in public places to praise my ‘Oxford speech’. My book on the same theme, An Era of Darkness, has stayed on Indian bestseller lists since its publication three months ago. This month, its British edition, Inglorious Empire: What the British Did to India has entered the bookstores in the colonial capital. The simple truth is that the British seized one of the richest countries in the world (accounting for 27% of global GDP in 1700) and, over 200 years of colonial rule, reduced it to one of the poorest, most diseased and most illiterate countries on earth by the time they left in 1947. They did so through practices of loot, expropriation, and outright theft, enforced by the ruthless wielding of brute power, conducted in a spirit of deep racism and amoral cynicism, and justified by a staggering level of hypocrisy and cant. Whether or not you agree with the American historian Will Durant that this was “the greatest crime in all human history”, it was certainly no exercise in benign altruism, as some disingenuous British apologists have described it.

I recently wrote to the Government of India to propose that one of India's most renowned heritage buildings, the Victoria Memorial in Kolkata, be converted into a museum that displays the truth of the British Raj - a museum, in other words, to colonial atrocities. This famous monument, built between 1906 and 1921, stands testimony to the glorification of the British Raj in India. It is time, I argued, that it be converted to serve as a reminder of what was done to India by the British.

It is curious that there is, neither in India nor in Britain, any museum to the colonial experience. London is dotted with museums that reflect its imperial conquests, from the Imperial War Museum to the India collections at the Victoria and Albert Museum and the British Museum itself. But none says anything about the colonial experience itself, the destruction of India's textile industry and the depopulation of the great weaving centres of Bengal, the systematic collapse of shipbuilding, or the extinction of India's fabled “wootz” steel. Nor is there any memorial to the massacres of the Raj, from Delhi in 1858 to Amritsar in 1919, the deaths of 35 million Indians in totally unnecessary famines caused by British policy, or the “divide and rule” policy that culminated in the horrors of Partition in 1947 when the British made their shambolic and tragic Brexit from the subcontinent. The lack of such a museum is striking.

Britain has been suffering from a kind of historical amnesia about colonialism. As my book emerged in India, an article by a Pakistani writer in The Guardian pointed out that the British simply don't teach their own schoolchildren the truth about their colonial past.  (She had raised two children in one of the best schools in London; they had studied history and never been taught a word about colonial history). Londoners look at the magnificence of their city with no idea of the loot and rapacity that paid for it. Many Brits are genuinely unaware of the atrocities committed by their ancestors, and some live in the blissful illusion that the Empire was some sort of civilising mission to uplift the ignorant natives.

The British tendency to brush colonial history under the carpet has been compounded by the gauzy romanticisation of Empire in assorted television soap operas that provide a rose-tinted view of the colonial era, glossing over the atrocities, exploitation, plunder and racism that were integral to the imperial enterprise.

Astonishingly, several British historians have written hugely successful books extolling what they see as the virtues of Empire. Many of the popular histories of the British Empire in the last decade or two, by the likes of Niall Ferguson and Lawrence James, have painted it in glowing colours. All this explains Britons' ignorance - but does not excuse it.

I'm not a fan of simple historical analogies, given the very different times we live in, but history always offers instructive lessons — as well as perspectives. As I say to young people in both Britain and India: if you don’t know where you've come from, how will you appreciate where you're going?

As for my fellow Indians, they have an admirable quality of being able to “forgive and forget”. I do want them to forgive — but not to forget.

My book is not intended to have any bearing on today's Indo-British relationship. That is now between two sovereign and equal nations, not between an imperial overlord and oppressed subjects. Indeed, when my book appeared in Delhi British Prime Minister Theresa May was days away from a visit to India seeking investment from India in her post-Brexit economy. As I’ve often argued, you don’t need to seek revenge upon history. History is its own revenge.

Tags: brexit, world war ii, jawaharlal nehru