Tuesday, Aug 04, 2020 | Last Update : 01:56 AM IST

133rd Day Of Lockdown

Maharashtra45019628703015842 Tamil Nadu2632222022834241 Andhra Pradesh166586886781537 Karnataka139571625002594 Delhi1384821242544021 Uttar Pradesh97362553931778 West Bengal78232548181731 Telangana6766048609551 Gujarat64684476632504 Bihar5956738508336 Rajasthan4555532051719 Assam4527633429109 Haryana3717330470440 Odisha3629723074248 Madhya Pradesh3428524099900 Kerala268731527885 Jammu and Kashmir2200614032407 Punjab1852711882442 Jharkhand135004794125 Chhatisgarh9820725661 Uttarakhand7800453890 Goa6816487656 Tripura5389360527 Puducherry3982241156 Manipur292017667 Himachal Pradesh2818165813 Nagaland21296574 Arunachal Pradesh175810633 Chandigarh116070619 Meghalaya9022645 Sikkim6882971 Mizoram4962660
  Opinion   Columnists  18 Mar 2018  Kashmir: Repression is at an all-time high

Kashmir: Repression is at an all-time high

The writer is an author and lawyer based in Mumbai
Published : Mar 18, 2018, 12:12 am IST
Updated : Mar 18, 2018, 12:13 am IST

A group called Hindu Ekta Manch called for a probe by the Central Bureau of Investigation, not the police in Kashmir.

Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti (Photo: PTI)
 Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti (Photo: PTI)

The sacking of Kashmir’s finance minister Haseeb Drabu by chief minister Mehbooba Mufti on March 12 will give a severe jolt to the People’s Democratic Party’s coalition with the Bharatiya Janata Party. He was its architect, in partnership with BJP general-secretary Ram Madhav (an Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh official seconded to the BJP). Madhav has declared that there is no Kashmir problem. Drabu said something very similar on March 9.

“Don’t see J&K as a conflict state and a political issue,” he posited. “It is not a political issue as far as I can see. They have been barking up the wrong tree for the last 50 or 70 years by talking about the politics of it, that the political situation has never improved. We seriously need to look at it in terms of how it is a society that is in search of itself.”


He spoke thus in New Delhi, where he was expected to project Kashmir’s viewpoint, at an event called “Kashmir: the Way Forward”. Instead, he berated Kashmiris for “barking up the wrong tree” by espousing their political cause. This covers not only the stooges whom New Delhi installed in power in Srinagar since August 8, 1953, when Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed Abdullah was thrown out in a coup, engineered by the Indian government, but Sheikh sahib also.

It confirmed the widely held suspicion that his eyes were set on New Delhi. He is the one who had drafted the PDP’s famous document Jammu & Kashmir: The Self-Rule Framework for Resolution. It envisaged not only drastic constitutional change to ensure “self-rule”, but also an accord between India and Pakistan. Paragraph 51 listed six “methods for consideration”; two were for a plebiscite; one was for elections “held under international supervision”; one more for an election and two others for steps based on these ideas. Six year later, he drafted with Madhav the PDP-BJP Agenda of the Alliance, which congealed the status quo of a deformed and hollowed out Article 370 (the so-called guarantee of autonomy).


Drabu’s boss, PDP supremo Mufti Mohammed Sayeed, desperately sought a return to power; if need be, by selling his people’s rights and his own soul. A former chief of RAW disclosed that he was in parleys with the BJP even during the elections. He justified the pact with the puerile remark that he was joining the North and South Poles.

That false partnership has come unstuck. BJP ministers in Kashmir, backed by the BJP government at the Centre, are defiant. So is Jammu. Kashmiris feel deceived. They had voted in large numbers for the PDP to keep out the BJP, whose proclaimed goal was to secure a majority in the Assembly by capturing all seats in Jammu and buying enough seats to form a majority in the Valley. Mufti opened the gates for the BJP.


On Mufti’s watch, pellet guns have been used by the Army. Infamously, a citizen was taken hostage by the Army, tied to the front of their jeep and paraded through the streets. Recent cases also expose both the Army’s behaviour and the BJP’s outlook.

On January 17, the body of a small girl from the Muslim Bakarwal nomadic community was found in Kathua in Jammu. She had been abducted, raped and killed. The police found that it was part of a conspiracy to force the nomads to quit in fear. Besides the main culprit, the police arrested SPO Deepak Khajuria and two other police officials for destroying evidence.

A group called Hindu Ekta Manch called for a probe by the Central Bureau of Investigation, not the police in Kashmir. It was set up specifically for this issue; its membership comprises the BJP as well as Congress men. Meetings were held at temples before marching in procession carrying the national flag. Two BJP ministers participated. The Manch complains of a “demographic invasion”; Jammu’s communal divide has widened.


Then, on March 4, two militants and four civilians were killed in Shopian. Contradicting the Army’s statement, Mufti herself called them “civilians caught in the crossfire” that day. By March 6 she denied this, and the fact that an FIR had been filed against Maj. Aditya Kumar — the day after the Supreme Court had forbidden its filing. The local police are sensitive to the people’s feelings. But it gets scant support from the chief minister. The Centre backs the Army.

Repression is systematic and at an all-time high. No leader commands the respect that the aged, ailing Syed Ali Shah Geelani does.

Yet he is singled out for attack. Under house arrest since October 2010, when Omar Abdullah was chief minister, neither his son nor even the vegetable vendor can enter his house. His wife needs eye surgery, for which he has no means.


It is a shame and disgrace. Why are India’s human rights activists and international rights organisations silent?

By arrangement with Dawn

Tags: mehbooba mufti, ram madhav