Thursday, Aug 06, 2020 | Last Update : 10:42 PM IST

135th Day Of Lockdown

Maharashtra46826530552116476 Tamil Nadu2734602148154461 Andhra Pradesh1864611043541681 Karnataka151449746792804 Delhi1402321261164044 Uttar Pradesh104388605581857 West Bengal83800589621846 Telangana7095850814576 Gujarat65704485612529 Bihar6203140760349 Assam4816233429115 Rajasthan4667932832732 Haryana3779631226448 Odisha3768124483258 Madhya Pradesh3508225414912 Kerala279561629988 Jammu and Kashmir2239614856417 Punjab1901512491462 Jharkhand140705199129 Chhatisgarh10109761369 Uttarakhand8008484795 Goa7075511460 Tripura5520367528 Puducherry4147253758 Manipur301818147 Himachal Pradesh2879171013 Nagaland24056594 Arunachal Pradesh179011053 Chandigarh120671520 Meghalaya9173305 Sikkim7832971 Mizoram5022820
  Opinion   Edit  04 Jul 2020  AA Edit | Immunity of Italian marines who shot Indians questionable

AA Edit | Immunity of Italian marines who shot Indians questionable

THE ASIAN AGE.
Published : Jul 4, 2020, 5:04 pm IST
Updated : Jul 4, 2020, 5:04 pm IST

It is perplexing that government of India chose to keep secret the order, which was issued on May 21 this year

File photo of Italian marines Salvatore Girone, left, and Massimiliano Latorre, arriving at the Ciampino Rome airport from Kochi, India. AP Photo
 File photo of Italian marines Salvatore Girone, left, and Massimiliano Latorre, arriving at the Ciampino Rome airport from Kochi, India. AP Photo

The verdict of an ad hoc tribunal of the Hague-based Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) that India has no jurisdiction to decide the case relating to the killing of two Indian fishermen off Kerala coast by two Italian marines on board a private oil tanker is regrettable.

The tribunal, constituted to settle disputes related to the United Nations Convention for the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), rejected India’s contention that Massimiliano Latorre and Salvatore Girone, accused of shooting and killing Ajeesh Pinky and Valentine in their boat St Antony on February 15, 2012, were not engaged in government service and hence cannot claim the privilege available to service personnel.

 

Instead, it accepted the Italian plea that the duo enjoyed immunity available to “state officials” and are exempted from the jurisdiction of the Indian courts.

The five-member tribunal comprising jurists from Russia, Jamaica and South Korea, apart from one each from India and Italy, by a majority vote also rejected India’s claims on the rights of a coastal state over its exclusive economic zone. The tribunal, however, ruled that the marines violated the protocols under UNCLOS, and hence must stand trial in Italy.

As per the order, India is, however, entitled to payment of compensation in connection with the loss of life and material damage to property and directed the two countries to consult with each other on the amount of compensation.

 

The immediate impact of the verdict is that the Supreme Court of India, which had sent the two marines home on bail, cannot proceed with the legal process in a case related to the killing of two Indian citizens as per Indian laws.

The National Investigation Agency has already slapped charges against the two Italians under sections of the Indian Penal Code related to murder, attempt to murder, mischief and common intent. The court had earlier stayed the proceedings as per an order of the ITLOS in 2015.

It is a travesty of justice if officials who are on security service on private enterprises are given state immunity but it is evident that India has been unsuccessful in convincing the tribunal about it.

 

This is important because UNCLOS speaks of immunity in case of warships and government-controlled vessels.

It is perplexing that government of India chose to keep secret the order, which was issued on May 21 this year, despite an order of the Supreme Court that the decisions of the tribunal must be communicated to it and the affected parties without delay.

The ministry of external affairs chose to comment on it only when the tribunal on its own issued a statement giving details of the order. Setbacks in international tribunals are not uncommon but attempts to keep them secret need an explanation from the government.

What is left to the government is to ensure that the two marines undergo trial as per the order of the tribunal and the families of the innocent victim get a decent compensation package. This is the least it can do to ensure justice for two slain Indian citizens.

 

Tags: italian marines